Deep Learning Pedagogy Training, Self-Assessed Pedagogical Competence, and Follow-Up Needs among Batam Community Learning Center Tutors
Abstract
Evaluating deep learning pedagogy training in Community Learning Centers (PKBM) requires distinguishing participants' evaluations of training delivery, self-assessed competence, and evidence of classroom application. This study examines these three dimensions and identifies follow-up support needs among PKBM tutors in Batam, Indonesia. A descriptive mixed-methods approach combined a survey of 46 tutors, written accounts from tutors and managers, and training-document review. Survey means and item-response distributions were compared descriptively with themes in the written accounts. Mean ratings across five training evaluation dimensions ranged from 4.46 to 4.61, with facilities and services rated highest (4.61). Mean self-assessment ratings across four pedagogical competence dimensions ranged from 4.29 to 4.33, led by learner-centered teaching (4.33). For items B7 and B15, respectively, 19.6% and 13.0% of tutors selected the moderately capable category. Written accounts described needs-informed planning and participatory activities but no structured system for monitoring subsequent teaching practice. Together, the findings identify a gap between favorable training evaluations and the evidence available to assess classroom application. Without pre-training measures, a comparison group, or classroom observations, competence gains and training effects cannot be inferred